For Buyers

In times of uncertainty, it’s good advice to focus more on what is known than unknown. Mortgage rate predictions have missed their marks repeatedly over the past 4 years, causing them to be a poor data point on which to base home buying decisions. The only rate that is known is the one averaging 7.4% as of October 21st.
A general rule of thumb to use with fluctuating rates is with each 0.1% fluctuation in the rate, add or subtract 1% on the principal and interest payment. Therefore, a payment quote of $2,500 for a loan around $360,000 at 7.4% will go down by roughly $25 at 7.3%. Buyers who purchase their home today at 7.4% do not need to stress under the uncertainty of where rates are going. If rates go up, they are set. If rates eventually go down again, they don’t miss out. They contact their lender, refinance the loan, and drop their payment.
It’s not all about the mortgage rate, however. When prices decline, buyers either get a little more home for their budget, or they get a lower payment for the same home. For example, if the mortgage rate goes up by 0.5%, the payment goes up 5%. However, if the price comes down 5% for the same home, the payment goes down 5%.
Here is a breakdown of where prices are dropping and where they are not:
For Sellers
Prices are holding up even as demand softens. The median sales price over the past month was $450,000, unchanged from the same period last year. Sellers should still be prepared for a longer wait. The median home that went under contract in that period was on the market for 50 days compared with 53 days a year ago, and 38 days two years ago.
Fewer homes are selling. Closings fell 9.8% to 5,155 over the past month compared with last year. September closings were 4.7% below September 2025, the second month in a row below last year after every month from January through July came in higher. New listings were down too, 9,287 over the past month against 9,618 a year earlier (-3.4%). Supply is building because fewer listings are selling, not because more are coming to market.
The luxury market is the exception. September closings over $1.5 million rose 25% from last year, 264 against 211, and 62 homes sold over $3 million compared with 57 last September. With contracts at their lowest mid-October level since at least 2011 and rates above 7%, closings are likely to stay below last year through the rest of the fall.
Sellers who price to where buyers are writing contracts today will be the ones who close before the holidays.
Our Take: Higher rates are testing buyers, but this isn’t a market standing still. Buyers have more options and more negotiating room than they’ve had in years, and sellers who price realistically and present their homes well are still getting deals done. In Scottsdale, where closings are up year to date, that’s especially true.
If you’re thinking about buying or selling, now is a good time to talk strategy and timing. Reach out and we’ll walk you through what this market means for your plans.
Commentary written by Tina Tamboer, Senior Housing Analyst with The Cromford Report
©2026 Cromford Associates LLC and Tamboer Consulting LLC
Did you enjoy this blog? Sign up for our E-News to have inspiration and information sent directly to your inbox!
About Mattisinko Group | Scottsdale, Arizona
Rob and Dani are dedicated to educating and guiding you toward wise decisions. Armed with in-depth market knowledge, pricing expertise, custom marketing strategies, and sharp negotiation skills, this team can help you reach your real estate and lifestyle goals. Call 480-REALTOR (732-5867).